from the great state of Toronto, Canada!

In: Music| Television

2 Jan 2007

Yup.  That’s how bandmate Gilby Clarke introduced Lukas Rossi, lead singer of the band Supernova after winning last fall’s reality TV show "Rockstar: Supernova".  You can read Jane Stevenson’s review as written in the Sun here.

All Canadian ignorance aside though, reading Stevenson’s review and some of the other related thoughts on their inaugural show, I can’t help but wonder about a few things with respect to reality TV for the purpose of creating a new celebrity money maker.

  • What are the factors that made Kelly Clarkson, Kelly Underwood and Clay Aiken rich and all the other American Idols to flop?  Same with the Canadians.  Some of it could be argued as talent I suppose, but certainly not all of it. 
  • How much longer will record labels pump money into artificially generated fan bases?  And is that considered a higher or lower risk compared to signing an indie band based on the size of their email list and the number of records they sold off the stage?
  • Do fans that were developed via reality TV have higher, lower, or the same lifetime value to the artist on average compared to fans who actually discovered a band, or actor, or porn star, or any other celebrity through more traditional channels.
  • Who makes more money–the producer of the reality TV show, the winning contestant, or that contestant’s interested third parties (agents, labels, movie studios, lawyers, etc.)?  And how does that compare to shares of the pie in a more traditional business arrangement like a major label record deal, independent record deal, movie deal, etc.?  Is this really just the media/entertainment industry fleecing the boy and girl next door?

How would you rather become famous?  The "old fashioned way" (whatever that entails) or the reality TV way?  Which would be more lucrative?  More sustainable?  More fulfilling?

Share/Save/Bookmark

Comment Form

About this blog

Formerly titled "one man's pop culture commentary", I've decided to re-label this for a few reasons:
(1) It's now home for all my online 'stuff'
(2) the search engines like it better
(3) the posts will be less pop-culture focused

Thanks for dropping by.

Find me online here:

email me my LinkedIn profile follow me on Twitter my Leslieviller profile my Facebook profile call me on Skype

Thanks to Janko for the free Handyicons 2 icon set.

  • Nolin: I like the analogy, Scott. Makes me wonder if/when there will be a PVR commercial-skipping or BitTo [...]
  • scott: Another great post and discussion. I say track away! And don't come for free content if you don' [...]
  • Axel: An interesting model, Nolin. A nice way to formalize the process. I would like to see how it applies [...]
  • Nolin: Good point on 'tone'. I need to dig into Scott's thinking still...thanks for the reminder. The r [...]
  • Axle Davids: "tone" - personality may be a more "plug and play" term "Extract / Transform / Infuse" @dmscott a [...]

My Recent Twitterings

Post Categories

Art (5)
B2B (1)
Books (1)
Business (15)
Current Affairs (11)
Film (4)
Food and Drink (1)
Games (1)
Marketing (23)
Media (12)
Music (12)
Politics (6)
Quirky Life (6)
Religion (1)
Science (1)
social media (4)
Television (10)
Things People Do (3)
Travel (2)
Uncategorized (1)
Web/Tech (16)
Weblogs (5)

WP Cumulus Flash tag cloud by Roy Tanck requires Flash Player 9 or better.